Thanks for sharing your initial reaction to the agave body sponge. It is coarser than the ayate, so it takes longer to fully blossom and soften. We recommend you soak it longer and continue using it in your shower to get it to the perfect consistency. It will soften and loosen up over time, making it easier to lather and cleanse. Since it is thicker than the ayate (because it's woven and contains more agave fibers), these tend to last longer. Keep us posted!